When we talk about tough competition and most fierce segment in automobile industry then sedans probably will be on top of that list. The reason behind is the increasing popularity, their charm and most importantly the affordability of sedan models. Other factors like quality, power-packed performance and last but not the least its sleek-attractive outside profile which undoubtedly creates a trendy-luxuriant image of its owner in society. And when we get more than one deserving same segment models then comparison surely rises.
We picked three leading cars of the segment to see which one is the ultimate boss. On one side there is Honda City, India’s most popular sedans of a time, second is Hyundai’s Verna which recently received an update and it is struggling to deliver good sales numbers to Hyundai but will new update help Verna? Let’s wait for some time. The third car of the lot is Volkswagen new Vento which despite of having comparatively new brand doing well in country. As Honda has equipped diesel variant in its City, Verna has been updated and Vento is getting second facelift in a year’s time and struggling to bring expected profit to its company, let’s see which one is capable to attract the sedan lovers actually.
|Base price||Top-end price|
|Petrol||7.53 lakhs||11.43 lakhs|
|Diesel||8.75 lakhs||11.84 lakhs|
|Petrol||7.75 lakhs||10.12 lakhs|
|Diesel||9.03 lakhs||12.22 lakhs|
|Petrol||7.85 lakhs||10.42 lakhs|
|Diesel||9.10 lakhs||11.87 lakhs|
To begin with trendy Honda’s Sedan City which is now available in diesel trim as well along with the petrol-one. While its diesel model carries price tags between 8.75-11.84 lakhs, petrol is as usual cheaper and comes with in the price bracket of 7.53-11.43 lakhs.
The second trendy model is by Hyundai which offers its sedan Verna at cost of 9.03-12.22 lakhs in diesel and 7.73-10.12 lakhs in petrol. While Verna’s diesel is costlier than City and comparatively dearer in its petrol trim.
And at last its trendy Vento which carries less margin between their price tags and its petrol model seems quite affordable than other rivals. While the Vento diesel is available at 9.10-11.87 lakhs, the petrol comes at price range of 7.85-10.42 lakhs.
And hence, as per the above mentioned price tags, while the Honda City is affordable in diesel trim and Verna in petrol. The Verna Diesel proves to be most expensive here, let’s see whether it will justify its price range ahead or not.
Coming to the mechanical powers of these three, all are equipped with two fuel units i.e. petrol and diesel. The Hyundai Verna is equipped with four types of engines, out of which two are petrol and two are diesel. Its 1.4 liter and 1.6 liter sized engines are marking their presence in both petrol and diesel trims. While diesel mills are responsible to develop 88.7bhp, 220Nm (in 1.4 liter) and 126.3bhp, 260Nm (in 1.6 liter), the petrol ones are good to churn out 105.5bhp, 135Nm (in 1.4 liter) and 121.3bhp, 155Nm (in 1.6 liter) of max power and peak torque respectively. What’s impressive about Verna is the availability of both manual and auto gearboxes in both petrol and diesel trims. It gets 6-speed manual in diesel and 5-speed manual in petrol while 4-speed automatic transmission is available in both.
And then it’s Honda’s powerful Sedan City which is not confusing in the no. of engines and available in straight forward two engines, one is petrol and other is diesel. While this City has borrowed the 1.5 liter 4-cyl petrol engine from its predecessor developing the max output n torque of 117.3bhp, 145Nm, the diesel engine is also of same sized 1.5 liter and churns out the max power and peak torque of 98.6bhp and 200Nm. But, the diesel engine of this trendy sedan only gets 6-speed manual gearbox while auto is missing, the petrol gets both 5-speed Manual and 5-speed Auto though.
Contrary, the German car Vento gets the tiniest 1.2 liter petrol mill in it which produces 103.5bhp and 175Nm on paper, but the interesting fact here is that this tiny mini engine is geared up with impressive 7-speed DSG automatic transmission. The other petrol engine of Vento is of 1.6 liter deriving similar power of 103.5bhp and least torque of153Nm and mated only to a 5-speed manual. The last but not the least engine, VW Vento is equipped with 1.6 liter diesel which again is offering similar power of 103.5bhp like its other engines while the torque is impressive of 250Nm and the engine is geared up with 5-speed manual and 7-speed DSG gearbox.
|Diesel||1.4 liter (88.7bhp, 220Nm)||1.6 liter (126.3bhp, 260Nm)|
|Petrol||1.4 liter (105.5bhp, 135Nm)||1.6 liter (121.3bhp, 155Nm)|
|Diesel||1.5 liter (98.6bhp, 200Nm)||—–|
|Petrol||1.5 liter (117.3bhp, 145Nm)||—–|
|Diesel||1.6 liter (103.5bhp, 250Nm)||—–|
|Petrol||1.2 liter (103.5bhp, 175Nm)||1.6 liter (103.5bhp, 153Nm)|
So, by considering above figures, new Verna’s still offers bigger diesel engine with its impressive figures and availability of auto gearbox resulting as a powerful-one, the Vento and Verna both are having a rub shoulder fight here in petrol trims. Must be thinking, City is like out of race form here, Right? But it’s not correct as there is a reason behind City’s least torque in diesel. Honda has designed its newly equipped diesel mill in such a way so that it can provide a better drivability and better fuel efficiency on road, and that’s why torque figures have been compromised here.
Honda City diesel offers a best in segment claimed fuel efficiency of 26.0 km/l over the 23.5-24.8km/l of Verna diesel and 21.50 km/l of Vento diesel. As far as their petrol mileage is concerned, story is repeating itself as Honda City here again offers better figures of 17.4-18.0 km/l over Verna’s 15.7-17.4 km/l and Vento’s 16.09-18.19 km/l.
But this is about the paper figures; let’s see how practical these cars are on roads. Honda City getting .25 extra marks over Vento just because of its diesel mill efficiency.
On road, the German car new Vento really does very well. The car remains stable at higher speeds and provides more than decent handling. Vento diesel is quick when driving and also one will feel bumps-less riding and confidence turning at the corners.
Though, if we see on paper, then Verna takes less time to reach 0-100 km/h but this figure surely doesn’t imply on the road and we found it a bit slow and seem to do hard effort when accelerating in city roads and this definitely is due to its throttle lag. Hyundai engineers have stiffened up the suspension a bit but still it is far away from segment benchmarks like Vento, Rapid and Fiesta.
Again, on paper, Vento diesel is the slowest among three in acceleration but in real world, it can surprise you with its ability. Further, the another point to be noted here is the refinement of Verna’s diesel engine with this facelift version, the diesel trim is comparatively noiseless, vibration-less and probably one of the most refined engine in segment. The steering of both City and Verna is much lighter as compared to the third-one Vento.
If compared all three together then City feels a little shorter on power, but if we drive it alone then this feeling doesn’t hit to our mind. The City diesel is free from turbo lag and which provides it a hustle free driving even on the city roads. Though, like the new Verna, City doesn’t get a refined engine which can be seen as a major drawback of it. The City’s engine makes noise but still we would say if ignore the fact of refinement then City definitely is the one which provides a better drivability and balanced handling on city roads as well as on highways. But it’s New Vento that takes away the cherry with its best in class handling and drivability even at higher speeds.
Space & dimension:
Dimension wise, while City is the longest and tallest among three, the Verna is the widest-one, on paper. Honda’s classy sedan is 4440mm long, 1695mm wide and 1495mm tall which gets tight competition by rival Verna which carries length of 4370mm, width of 1700mm and height of 1475mm. Contrary, Vento by VW also has a nice proportioned dimension and gets length, width and height of 4390mm, 1699mm and 1467mm respectively.
The all-new City again scores more by having comparatively more wheelbase of 2600mmover the 2570mm of Verna and 2553mm of Vento. This longer wheelbase of City provides it more and sufficient legroom at rear seats, the Verna and Vento also gets nice legroom and headroom though but City is still the best here and the most comfortable one. But when it comes to best in class cabin space especially the rear space, Maruti Suzuki Ciaz beats them all single handedly.
Apart from the dimension, one more thing which makes the Honda’s City better in this section is its wonderful large boot of 510 liters over the 494 liters of Vento (up by 8 liters) and 465 liters of Verna. Honda has really done a great job by updating its City as it now has a way better space at inside cabin than before. And due to City’s large dimension and better space availability, we give it half point more here.
Space & dimension Scores:
At inside cabin, both Honda and Hyundai has made the story worth watching by providing a trendier and impressive interior cabin in their respective sedans. While Verna is carrying a dual toned dashboard along with wood and silver inlays, City gets a glossy black dash in it. The finishing of material quality is good in both but definitely better in Hyundai’s Verna. Contrary, the third sedan by Vento is getting a plain interior which somehow looks dull in front of Hyundai’s and Honda’s sedan.
On the name of interior equipments, Honda City gets one push engine start/stop button along with smart entry key system, auto AC with touchscreen control panel and heater, rear AC vent, rear parking camera, cruise control, electrically foldable & adjustable ORVM, keyless entry, steering mounted controls, bluetooth, USB, Aux-in, rear reading light, rear defogger, coat hanger and clock etc.
Further, Hyundai’s classy sedan is designed with features like keyless entry, auto AC, electrically adjustable & foldable outside rear view mirror, cooled glove box, front seat armrest – sliding with box, rear parking sensors, rear center armrest with box, tilt and telescopic steering wheel with mounted controls, 2DIN audio system with bluetooth, USB, Aux-in etc.
while Volkswagen’s Vento gets 3 grab handles above doors, folding with coat hooks, rear centre armrest, ‘climatronic’ auto air-conditioning, rear parking sensors, steering mounted controls, bluetooth, USB, Aux-in, rear defogger, central locking system, speed sensing auto door locks etc.
Still, comparatively, Vento lacks in features somehow, new Verna does get many new and modern types of equipment inside but not getting a touchscreen unit is a disappointment last but not the least Honda’s City which is offering more features than both Verna and Vento.
These more features of City include three view modes in rear parking camera (wide, normal, top-down view), rear AC vents, touch-screened climate control etc while Verna on the other side has single view rear camera and rear AC vent etc is missing from it. And hence, for the extra and advanced features equipment in City, we give more score to it.
In this section of looks of a car where Honda’s City carries eye-catching glimpse and Verna is not far behind in any terms here as well. Contrary, Vento yet again disappoints here with its plain not-so-classy outside profile. In the latest update new Vento gets revamped front fascia in the form of three slat chrome grille, revised bonnet with deeper and downward crease, new front bumper with redesigned air dams and horizontal slats, new double barrel halogen headlamps with smoked effect and fog lamp units with cornering light function. The new Vento is by far the best looking Vento till date but still misses the charm of City and Verna.
The sharply designed curves, well-finished lines of City along with features like chromed front grille, classy alloy wheels, shark fin antenna, turn indicator on ORVM and stylish electric sunroof make the Honda’s sedan smarter and glossier than ever.
But wait, we didn’t say that Verna doesn’t have anything. New Verna gets even more in-style features like newly designed alloy wheels in top segment, projector headlamps, L shaped LED lights around the fog lamps, illuminated switches inside the cabin which surely are good enough to take over the Honda’s City and make the Verna best-in-segment.
The built quality and quality of material used is just superb in City, Verna and Vento as well, but as discussed above it’s the charmless and simple design of Vento the least good looking car here comparatively.
The VW Vento is a sedan with many plus points like its powerful engines, decent handling, and solid built quality but where it lacks is the exterior profile and comparatively less equipments. Contrary, Verna is a superb looking car with lots of equipments and also engine refinement but yet again if compares then it seems lack in driving with ease in traffics, less comfortable at inside etc while our third competitor Honda City gets only one major issue and that is engine refinement otherwise its appealing in almost every other section including driving pleasure, features, equipments, comfort, practical and last but not the least, it’s cheap maintenance cost post buying.
|Comparison of Honda City|
|Comparison of Honda City variants|